By Joanne P. Shelby-Klein BSN RN
How many times have you made the comment “my body must need something because I feel like I am craving chocolate, steak, liver etc.” and then proceeded to grab the particular food desired? Many times we have said that we are craving a certain food and linked it to something specifically lacking in our bodies. That is a belief that has been around for many years. Research has shown that there is some truth to that belief about cravings, but there is more to it than that. Why do we get these strong needs or desires for certain foods at certain times, is it more than just our bodies needing a nutrient?
WHAT IS A CRAVING?
A ‘craving’ can be defined as an overwhelming desire, interest in or yearning for something, usually food. According to the American Society of Nutritional Sciences in 2003, about 97% of women and 68% of men have had at least one episode of food cravings. These cravings act as a motivation to find a certain food and act as a reminder that you won’t be satisfied or happy until we have had that one food. For many people these food cravings such as for barbeque chips, chocolate, special ice creams etc., eating a small portion of the food satisfies the craving and it goes away. For other people, the craving and subsequent eating of the food can lead to periods of binge eating and problems such as large weight gain, obesity and other eating disorders. The USDA Human Nutrition Research Center on Aging did a study on 32 overweight women who were placed on a diet. The most commonly craved foods among these 32 women were things like salty chips and French fries and sweets like chocolate that are very high in sugars and fats.
WHERE DOES THIS CRAVING COME FROM?
Researchers are still trying to answer that question. One study reported in Psychology and Behavior that healthy males and females were placed on a diet that met all of their nutritional needs through daily consumption of nutritional shakes in place of meals for 5 days. The study participants reported more cravings than when eating a diet rich in a variety of foods, leading the researchers to believe that it was not a nutritional lack that was causing the cravings but instead a monotonous diet.
Other research studies have shown that mental images of the craved food may play a big part in the craving itself. The more vivid and realistic the mental picture of the food, the more intense the craving. Study participants were found to be able to recall fewer words and solve less math problems when they were craving chocolate compared to participants who were not craving chocolate. Research is being conducted to determine if cognitive tasks such as solving math problems can help to curb and stop cravings for items such as chocolate.
Other research theories have focused on a connection between cravings for carbohydrates and sugars may be connected to mood, as people may take in more carbohydrates to treat a low mood or stress levels and use it to elevate their moods. The theory suggests that taking in carbohydrates may trigger an increase in the brains neurotransmission chemical serotonin which can elevate mood and regulate appetite.
Hormones may also be involved in the yearning or craving for certain foods. What happens is, we eat a food we enjoy and thanks to hormone receptors in the body we get a happy or pleasurable feeling. Over time, as we eat the foods that bring us the happy feeling can become dulled as the hormone receptors become used to the food and don’t release the feeling of pleasure. This causes us to feel a need to eat more and more of that food to make us feel satisfied.
Along with the hormones playing a role in cravings, so too can memories. Certain foods can be associated with certain emotions and memories. Smelling a certain smell or seeing a certain photograph can bring back a specific memory or emotion and trigger a sudden intense desire or craving for the food.
Stress can also bring about a desire for certain foods, like chocolate, perhaps causing binge eating of the food. So, too, can certain times of the day cause a sudden desire for chocolate or something sweet. Stress eating and cravings at certain times of the day can be more pronounced if you are tired or hungry.
WHAT IS MOST CRAVED FOOD?
Chocolate is the most craved food in North America. 40% of women and 15% of men admit that they crave chocolate. Some these men and women admit a preference for any food that is sweet but often find that other sweet foods do not satisfy their cravings like chocolate does.
This leads to a question of why is chocolate the most craved food and not broccoli or kale. Some scientific studies have shown that chocolate naturally contains some ingredients that act like psychologically active agents. These include:
- Theobromine which is a weak stimulant that acts on the central nervous system.
- Anandamide, a cannabinoid contained naturally in the chocolate.
- Phenylethalamine , a weak substance that works like amphetamine.
Chocolate is also naturally high in magnesium, an important element needed by the body for bone and muscle health. This has led to the suggestion that people who crave chocolate may be lacking magnesium in their body. However, there are other foods high in magnesium such as nuts, that are not craved or when eaten do not stop the craving.
IS IT POSSIBLE TO STOP A CRAVING WITHOUT EATING THE FOOD?
There are some tricks to try and beat a craving, especially if you are on a weight loss diet or have food restrictions.
- Aromatherapy, using a non-food scent can be a great way to stop a food craving. A study conducted at Flinders University in Australia, showed that smelling a scent, such as Jasmine, lessened the craving for chocolate.
- Take a walk or walk on a treadmill. A British study reported that walking on a treadmill decreased the craving or need for chocolate.
- If all else fails, give in and eat a small amount of the food you are craving, sometimes just a taste will work. Do this occasionally, not all the time and keep the amount eaten small.
WHAT IS A PICA AND HOW IS IT DIFFERENT FROM A CRAVING?
A Pica can be thought of as an unusual form of a craving. Pica usually involves craving something that is not food or has no nutritional value at all and is usually consumed in large quantities. Pica is the Latin term for Magpie or a bird believed to constantly seek out items to satisfy its curiosity. With a dietary Pica, a human being does the same with an unusual nonfood substance. There are 8 common forms of pica listed below:
- Geophagia, dirt or clay eating.
- Clthonophagia, old term for dirt eating
- Lithophagia, eating stones or gravel
- Amlophagia, eating starch or starch products like play dough for example
- Pagophagia, or ice eating
- Geomelophagia, eating raw unskinned potatoes
- Cautopyreiophagia,eating burnt matches or cigarette ashes
- Trichophagia, eating hair
For most people, a pica is considered a compulsive, repetitive behavior but is not considered to be a psychological disorder. A pica is usually a result of an undiagnosed or unnoticed medical condition such as iron deficiency anemia. Picas are often not noticed by healthcare providers because people are often embarrassed about their unusual eating habit. Most health care providers will find out about a pica when they talk to patients about their diets. If you are eating anything unusual, it is important to mention it to your healthcare provider by mentioning what you eat and when. You may not even realize that what you are doing is a pica but may merely think of it as a food habit or routine. If you are doing something that you think may be a pica or see a family member doing something for more than 1 month that may be a pica behavior, mention it to a healthcare provider and ask questions about it. A healthcare provider can do a thorough exam to find out what may be causing the problem.
WHAT CAUSES A PERSON TO HAVE A PICA?
Evaluation for a pica should be based on what the patient reports eating on a regular basis as well as any unusual symptoms of infections, poisonings and toxicity.
- Blood work may show high levels of unusual substances such as lead.
- The patient may have an unusual parasite infection and be very sick.
- The patient may show signs of gastro-intestinal problems such as bowel blockage, severe constipation, and ulcers.
- Tooth abrasions, and other unusual dental issues
- Low levels of iron, zinc, calcium, magnesium, thiamin, niacin and vitamins C and D indicating a deficiency may be noticed.
WHO IS AT RISK FOR DEVELOPING A PICA?
- People who are of a lower socio-economic class most often seen in children eating lead paint.
- Early separation of children from parents (especially from mothers), parents who neglect or abuse children, or parents who interact poorly with their children.
- People with intellectual and mental disabilities who are unable to tell the difference between food and non- food.
- Pregnant women are at risk for pica especially if they are not taking in enough healthy nutrients.
- People who have cultural traditions that involve pica or learned pica type eating habits from family members.
WILL PICA GO AWAY ON ITS OWN OR IS IT A PERMANENT PROBLEM?
Picas will often go away on their own in young children and in pregnant women once the nutritional related issue such as iron deficiency is resolved. However, Picas can last for many years in people who are intellectually challenged or disabled and can lead to very serious medical problems if left untreated. Damage done by lead poisoning is often permanent. People can develop high potassium levels in the blood, usually from ingesting ashes or burnt cigarettes, causing the muscles, especially the heart, to not work properly.
WHAT SYMPTOMS WILL A PERSON WITH PICA HAVE?
It depends on what is causing the Pica and what the person is eating.
- Lead poisoning: most often seen in young children who are irritable or cranky, lethargic or very sleepy, uncoordinated or unusual movements, headache, seizures, coma or even death.
- Parasite infections from eating dirt or clay often show with fever, enlarged liver, general tiredness, coughing, and vision loss.
- Gastro-intestinal issues such as constipation, bowel obstruction, vomiting blood or coffee ground type material, dark stools that resemble tar indicating bleeding.
There is currently one specific test that can tell if a pica is present. Children between the ages of 1 and 2 can be checked for blood levels of lead. If a person is having GI symptoms an x-ray of the abdomen may be done as well as an upper and lower GI examination using barium. The tests may be repeated on a periodic basis to track movement and changes in the objects seen.
TREATMENT FOR PICA
A healthcare team approach is best for working with a patient (especially those who are intellectually disabled) with a pica. A dietitian or nutritionist may help in identifying eating patterns and nutritional deficiencies. A psychologist or psychiatrist and a social worker may be helpful in changing the behavior patterns that go along with Pica eating as well as starting behavior changing plans to eliminate the pica.
- Teach the difference between items that are edible and safe to eat and items that are inedible or unsafe to eat.
- Provide and instruct in the use of self-protective devices that will keep pica objects out of the mouth
- May need to cover the eyes briefly when the pica is started so the object cannot be seen
- Use a bitter taste such as lemon on the pica object to discourage eating
- May need to gently remove the persons hand from the object to re-inforce it should not be placed in the mouth.
Medical intervention may also include correcting iron deficiency anemia with iron pills, injections or intravenously. Serotonin inhibitor medications such as escitalopram can be given to help decrease the desire for the object. Frequent follow up with the healthcare team is also necessary.
As you can see Cravings and Picas are similar but very different with Picas being the more serious of the two. If you suspect that you or a family member maybe dealing with unusual cravings or picas, make an appointment to discuss in detail with your healthcare provider.
- Yanovski, S. (2003). Sugar and Fat, Cravings and Aversions. JN, The Journal of Nutrition. March 1, 2003 vol. 133 no. 3 835S-837S.
- Khan, Y. Tisman, G. (2010). Pica in Iron Deficiency: A Case Series. Journal of Medical Case Reports. 2010, 4:86 doi:10.1186/1752-1947-4-86 The electronic version of this article is the complete one and can be found online at: http://www.jmedicalcasereports.com/content/4/1/86
- Ellis, CR, MD. Pataki, C, MD. (2014). Pica. eMedicine Medscape. Retrieved from URL: http://emedicine.medscape.com/article/914765-overview
- Mishori, R MD MHS. McHale, C MD. (2014). Pica: An age old eating disorder that is often missed. Journal of Family Practice. 2014; July 63(7): E1-E4. Retrieved from URL: http://www.jfponline.com/the-publication/past-issue-single-view/pica-an-age-old-eating-disorder-thats-often-missed/a97dbe0f00af44738fd1b5f4e2353a6a.html
- Walker HK, Hall WD, Hurst JW, editors. Clinical Methods: The History, Physical, and Laboratory Examinations. 3rd edition. Boston: Butterworths; 1990. Chapter 148.
- Kemps, E. Current Directions in Psychological Science. Retrieved from URL: https://www.psychologicalscience.org/index.php/news/releases/the-psychology-of-food-cravings.html
- Fesler, K. (2014, February).The Craving Brain. Tufts Nutrition Magazine. Retrieved from URL: http://now.tufts.edu/articles/craving-brain